| FIDIC |
Home Site search Site map Contact FIDIC New News Directories Calendars Products Account |
| BOOKSHOP | EVENTS | USER FORUMS | INTERNAL | YPs | REGIONS | FEDERATION | ||||||||
| Welcome Contracts Practice Capacity Building Industry | ||||||||||||||
| The FIDIC's 1999 Forms of Contract |
| FIDIC's Assessment Panel for Adjudicators |
| Peter L Booen & Gordon L Jaynes Published in Engineers Australia and Building and Construction Law, 2001. |
| Readers who are involved in the international construction industry, and especially those involved in projects financed by the World Bank and the Asian Development Bank, will be interested in the recent developments with respect to FIDIC’s well-known forms of contract. FIDIC’s new suite of documents are certain to have a significant effect on the future of this industry and on those whose firms are engaged in it. The suite contains many new and changed provisions of which all practitioners should be aware. The FIDIC Contracts Guide to the new forms is of particular interest. |
| Background |
| The Fédération Internationale des Ingénieurs-Conseils (FIDIC) is the
international federation of consulting engineers. Its membership is largely
comprised of national associations, such as the Association of Consulting
Engineers Australia (www.acea.aust.com).
FIDIC is best known as the organisation that publishes standard forms of contract documents related to the procurement of engineering works. These standard forms include those for use by consulting engineers, and other forms that are suitable for the procurement of building and engineering works. FIDIC’s previous standard forms of contract documents for building and engineering works have been known by the colours of their respective covers:
|
| The New Suite |
Although the above standard forms are still widely used internationally,
FIDIC has replaced them by the following First Editions, published in September
1999:
The FIDIC Contracts Guide includes some material that may be considered useful for the training of personnel in procurement. However, it does not provide complete training material for the expertise required for the preparation of tender documents. The comments in FIDIC’s Guide are intended to assist users of the Conditions, namely those who write or administer building and/or engineering contracts, who should have the necessary expertise in contractual and procurement aspects. Please visit the FIDIC Bookshop to order these publications, either in hard copies or electronically downloaded.* |
| Drafting Principles |
One particular principle, which was applied throughout the drafting of the
new suite, was to facilitate the preparation of the Conditions of Contract for
each contract. Unlike most other published form of Conditions, those published
by FIDIC recognise the reality that the tender documents for a particular
project typically have to include provisions which are not appropriate for other
projects. Preparation of the tender documents has been facilitated by:
|
| Some New Features |
|
In addition to extensive rewording (and re-sequencing) of existing
provisions, the 1999 Editions include some new provisions. For example,
Sub-Clause 2.4 requires the Employer to submit (if requested) reasonable
evidence that he has effected financial arrangements which will enable him to
pay the final Contract Price; as estimated at that time. If the Contractor does
not receive such evidence, Clause 16 entitles him to suspend work or reduce the
rate of work, and ultimately (if no evidence is received within 12 weeks) to
terminate the contract.
Sub-Clause 2.5 sets out the procedure that the Employer must follow if he wishes to claim payment from the Contractor: typically, for default. The Employer is not entitled to withhold an interim payment for reasons that were not previously notified to the Contractor with particulars substantiating the Employer’s claim. In the Conditions of Contract for Construction and those for Plant & Design-Build, Clause 3 describes the role of the Engineer. Unlike previous editions, the Engineer does not act impartially, but is deemed to act for the Employer; however, it is relatively straightforward for the Particular Conditions to require the Engineer to act impartially when making his "fair determinations" under Sub-Clauses 3.5, 14.6 and 14.13. Under Sub-Clause 3.4, the Contractor may object to a proposed replacement Engineer within six weeks after the Employer notifies "the name, address and relevant experience of the intended replacement Engineer". Sub-Clause 4.2 requires the Contractor to provide a Performance Security. When preparing the tender documents, the Employer has to decide what form of security he requires. Although not forming part of the General Conditions, example wording has been proposed incorporating (by reference) Uniform Rules published by the International Chamber of Commerce ("ICC"):
Clause 12 of the Conditions of Contract for Construction covers measurement and valuation of the Works, and allows a Bill rate to be amended if (i) its measured quantity is changed by more than 10%, (ii) this change in quantity multiplied by the Bill rate exceeds 0.01% of the total contract price, and (iii) this change in quantity (and no other cause) directly changes the cost per unit quantity of the item by more than 1%. Clause 13 covers Variations, and adjustments for changes in legislation and in cost. Variations are not immediately binding if the Contractor promptly notifies that he cannot readily obtain the required Contractor’s Equipment, Materials, Plant or Temporary Works. In the case of Contractor-design, Variations are also not binding if the Contractor promptly notifies that the proposed Variation will have an adverse impact on safety, suitability, or the achievement of the specified performance criteria. If he so notifies, the Contractor can then await confirmation (or otherwise) of the Variation. Clause 18 covers insurances, most of which are required to be arranged by the "insuring Party": which is defined as the Contractor unless otherwise stated in the Particular Conditions. The provisions thus provide for the possibility that the Employer may wish to effect some of the insurances: namely, by defining himself as the insuring Party in respect of such insurances. |
| Claims and Disputes |
|
Clause 20 covers the submission of claims and the settlement of disputes.
Sub-Clause 20.1 sets out the procedure that the Contractor must follow in
respect of claims for extension of time and claims for extra payment.
Sub-Clause 20.2 provides for the appointment of a dispute adjudication board ("DAB"), which makes the pre-arbitral decisions in respect of disputes. Dispute Boards have been in use world-wide since 1995 on projects receiving financing from the World Bank and the Asian Development Bank. They are a major change from the older practice of using the Employer’s Engineer as the maker of pre-arbitral decisions, and have had a significant impact on the industry and on the work of the engineering and legal professions involved in it. Terms for the DAB’s agreements are appended to the General Conditions. Alternative wording has been proposed for use on contracts where impartial pre-arbitral decisions are to be made by the Engineer, instead of an independent DAB, similar to the arrangements under the old Red and Yellow Books. The use of a DAB was included in the Orange Book, and was later offered (as an alternative arrangement) in the 1995 Supplement to the Red Book. Sub-Clause 20.4 specifies the procedure under which the DAB makes its decision on a dispute. The decision is immediately binding and both Parties must comply with it, unless and until it is revised in an amicable settlement or arbitration. It is therefore essential that the members of the DAB are expert professionals and independent of each other, of each Party, and of each partner of a joint venture Party; and are acceptable to both Parties. In order to deal with the possibility that the Parties cannot agree upon the membership of the DAB, Sub-Clause 20.3 provides for an appointing entity to be required to name a member if called upon to do so. The FIDIC Contracts Guide indicates that FIDIC is prepared to perform the role of appointing entity under Sub-Clause 20.3, if the Contract language is English and this appointing entity is defined as "the President of FIDIC or a person appointed by the President". In order for it to be able to act as appointing entity, FIDIC has established an "Assessment Panel for Adjudicators", and required it to set a high standard for FIDIC’s "President’s List of Approved Adjudicators". Those interested in being included in the President’s List of Approved Adjudicators can obtain further details from FIDIC’s website. It lists the criteria for inclusion on the List, including satisfactory assessment at FIDIC’s Adjudication Assessment Workshop, where attendees are subjected to rigorous testing and their performance as DAB members is assessed. Consideration is currently being given to arranging a seminar in Australia on these FIDIC 1999 Forms of Contract and, possibly, to FIDIC arranging an Adjudication Assessment Workshop also. However, such Workshops are arranged in response to demand, namely when a sufficient number of prospective listees apply to attend a FIDIC Workshop, which has not yet happened. Will FIDIC receive sufficient applications from engineers and construction lawyers in the region for an Adjudication Assessment Workshop to be arranged in Australia? * FIDIC publications are also obtainable in Australia.
|
|
International Federation of Consulting Engineers FIDIC Bookshop- Box 311 - CH-1215 Geneva 15 - Switzerland Tl +41-22-799 49 00 - Fx +41-22-799 49 01 - fidic.pub@fidic.org - FIDIC Bookshop |